Concept · part of How people actually believe things

You have never measured the distance to the Sun or audited your bank. What you believe about both rests on who told you. That is how everyone handles a world too big to check first-hand: a claim from a source you trust counts for more than the same claim from a stranger.

Cailin O’Connor and James Owen Weatherall, in The Misinformation Age, put this habit at the center of their models of how groups form beliefs. The book calls it credibility weighting and treats it as rational and unavoidable. No one has the time or attention to verify everything.

It is also a weak point. Whoever can manufacture or buy credibility gets false evidence carried as readily as true, which makes trust a prime manipulation surface. And it gets heavier use as checking gets harder. When publishing became free, the work of judging quality moved onto readers, who fall back on the cheapest shortcut available: trust by familiarity.

When two groups start out slightly apart, each sensibly discounts the other’s sources and the gap widens. The book calls that polarization via distrust. It is also why any institution that vets on readers’ behalf depends on trust it can lose.

Read the full argument

How it connects


← Justification market (behavior→belief arrow) · How people actually believe things (5 of 7) · Conformity →

Explore all the ideas · Read the book in order · Open the interactive map