Concept · part of Truths made by agreement
A dog, a toothache and a twenty-dollar bill are all real, in three different ways. The dog is there whether or not anyone believes in it. The toothache exists in one mind only. The twenty buys groceries because enough people agree that it does.
Yuval Noah Harari, in Nexus, names these three realities: objective, subjective and intersubjective. Currencies, nations, laws, brands and religions belong to the third. They have real consequences (you can be arrested for breaking a law), and those consequences exist because a network of people agrees they do.
The book borrows the split because its account of how ideas travel treats each kind differently. A claim about the objective world can be garbled on its way to an audience while the fact itself stays put, which is what a correction appeals to in a case like arsenic-life. Subjective states mostly do not travel at all. Shared agreements are the odd case: passing them along helps make them real. For those, the danger is someone steering how the agreement gets made, often behind the belief that it is a fact of nature. The book sorts the outcomes into three states an agreement can be in.
Read the full argument
- Chapter 2: Case Studies and Three Realities, section “The three realities”
- Chapter 2: Case Studies and Three Realities, section “What the third reality changes”
- Chapter 8b: Intersubjective Truth, section “Two truths, one experiment”
How it connects
- Examples: Apartheid race classification
- See also: Black-Scholes and the option market, Constitutive regimes (convergent / divergent / hollow), Constitutive transmission, Looping effects, Reification, Truth generators (reality vs. agreement), What does the pipeline do to intersubjective truths?
- Where the book discusses it: Chapter 2: Case Studies and Three Realities, Chapter 5: The Complexity / Virality Trade-off, Chapter 5b: Selection As The Other Engine, Chapter 5c: Truth, Compression, and When Each Wins, Chapter 8: Preservation vs. Training, Chapter 9: The Integration Problem, Chapter 10: Political Economy of Attention, Chapter 11: AI as a New Kind of Node, Chapter 12: Infrastructure for Integration
Truths made by agreement (1 of 6) · Truth generators (reality vs. agreement) →
Explore all the ideas · Read the book in order · Open the interactive map