Open question · part of The medium sets the rules
A platform caps posts at a few hundred characters. A long, careful argument does not fit. One way to describe what happened: the careful argument has been removed from that platform, full stop. Another: it now costs extra (a thread, a link, a screenshot of text), so most people skip it and a few still manage.
The book first took the hard line. Chapter 5b says an idea the menu of available forms cannot hold never needs suppressing, because it never forms. The research on frameworks pushes back. Where the hard version has been tested, mostly on language, it has mostly failed: people can think things their words make awkward (piraha-numbers).
Where the book now lands: mostly a price. A medium rarely forbids a thought. It makes it expensive, and across a large population expensive thoughts become rare (framework pricing, influence, not imprisonment). Two limits apply. A strict physical cap really does exclude what cannot fit. And a price nobody pays for a generation may harden into a wall (lock-in). The answer is provisional and rests on a survey of the evidence the author has not yet read at the source.
Status: provisionally resolved.
The working answer, in the author’s words
Price, not wall, at the scale of an individual and a year; close to a wall at the scale of a population and a generation. A framework (and by extension a medium) rarely forbids a thought; it prices it, and across a population the expensive variant mostly does not form. The remedy differs: a price can be paid (effort, training, subsidy, a second framework). The time-scale caveat from medium-and-manipulation carries over: a price nobody has paid for a generation, because the training that lets people pay it has hollowed out, behaves like a wall (lock-in). Hard capacity limits (a 160-character cap) remain genuine walls for the forms they exclude. Drafted in thinking-inside-frameworks.md; rests on a secondhand survey of the evidence.
Read the full argument
- Thinking Inside Frameworks, section “The price list, not the wall”
- Thinking Inside Frameworks, section “Where I’m still uncertain”
How it connects
- Leads to: A framework prices thoughts; it rarely forbids them
- See also: Framework pricing, Influence, not imprisonment, Option space, Path dependence and lock-in
- Raised in: Chapter 5b: Selection As The Other Engine, Medium and Manipulation, Thinking Inside Frameworks
← What does the medium do to the gates? · The medium sets the rules (8 of 8)
Explore all the ideas · Read the book in order · Open the interactive map