Example · part of How ideas travel

Ten kids sit in a circle. The first whispers a sentence to the second, who whispers it to the third, and so on. What the last child says out loud barely resembles the original. Nobody lied. Each child passed on what they heard.

The book uses the game as its plainest picture of transport: the loss in every retelling. If each retelling has a 90 percent chance of keeping an idea intact, ten retellings leave about a one-in-three chance it arrives clean, and a hundred leave almost none. That compounding is why the book says a large network puts a ceiling on how complicated an idea can be and still cross it, and why short, simple versions travel.

The book also says the game cheats. Its one rule is that every player must pass the message on. Real networks have no such rule. People choose whether to pass a thing along at all, to whom, and in which version. That choice is selection, and the game leaves it out. So the telephone game explains what happens to an idea that keeps moving. Cases like two books from the same printing press show the other half: which ideas get to move.

Read the full argument

How it connects


← Transport · How ideas travel (2 of 11) · Selection →

Explore all the ideas · Read the book in order · Open the interactive map