Theme 7 of 13 · 6 ideas

Most of the book treats ideas as reports about a world that does not care what we think. Some truths are different: they exist because enough people hold them. For those, the chain of retellings is wired into the thing itself.

The same ground, told as a story: Chapter 2: Case Studies and Three Realities, Chapter 8b: Intersubjective Truth.

The ideas

Each one is a short page. Walk them in this order, or start with whichever catches your eye.

  1. Three realities (Harari): Some things are true whatever anyone thinks, some only inside one mind, and some only because enough people agree, like money or laws.
  2. Truth generators (reality vs. agreement): Two statements can both be true while one is made true by the world and the other only by people continuing to agree.
  3. Constitutive transmission (mechanism): When something is real only because people agree on it, every retelling adds to or drains the agreement, so spreading the news changes the thing.
  4. Constitutive regimes (convergent / divergent / hollow): A shared agreement like money or law can hold together, split into rival versions, or survive in words only while people stop acting on it.
  5. Reification: People forget that money, markets and laws are arrangements humans made and could remake, and start treating them like facts of nature.
  6. What does the pipeline do to intersubjective truths? (open question): Retelling can garble a fact but never change it, while for things true only by agreement, like money, the retelling helps decide what is true.

← What shortening does to truth · All themes · What the filter rewards →