Example · part of Thinking inside frameworks

During the 2003 Columbia mission, Boeing engineers briefed NASA managers on possible damage from a foam strike. They used slides. One headline read “Review Of Test Data Indicates Conservatism for Tile Penetration.” The caveat that the test data were for far smaller debris sat lower down, buried in nested bullets.

The accident investigation board adopted Edward Tufte’s analysis of that slide. Its report said it was easy to see how a senior manager could read it “and not realize that it addresses a life-threatening situation.” The board was also surprised, at many points, to be handed slides where it expected technical reports.

A slide deck is a framework for thinking. It makes bullet hierarchies cheap and sustained argument costly, a cost asymmetry that shapes what gets said. The book calls the menu of forms a medium allows its option space. Here the menu favored the compressed form of a warning, and slides stood in for technical reports. The book describes the same substitution at AI scale as the summary that replaces the source.

Keep the scale in mind. This is one slide in one accident, and the board documented many organizational causes at length.

How solid is this? Officially endorsed (the accident board adopted Tufte’s analysis), but a single case in which the slide was one factor among many organizational causes.

Read the full argument

How it connects


← Defaults · Thinking inside frameworks (5 of 21) · Notation as a tool of thought →

Explore all the ideas · Read the book in order · Open the interactive map