Concept · part of Thinking inside frameworks

Describe crime as a beast preying on a city, and people favor enforcement more than people told it is a virus infecting the city. In the experiment both groups saw the same crime statistics (crime-metaphor).

George Lakoff and Mark Johnson argued in 1980 that people understand abstract things through metaphors borrowed from concrete ones (argument as war, time as money), and that the borrowed picture brings its logic with it. If argument is war, there are winners, positions and attacks, and it becomes harder to think of an argument as a joint search.

The experimental support is real and smaller than first reported. The crime result has been both challenged and replicated, and it depends on the metaphor arriving early. For the book a conceptual metaphor is a compact framework, and a kind of framing that travels well because it is short. That makes it powerful in the zone where expert findings are retold for everyone else: the metaphor survives compression and the qualifications do not.

Read the full argument

How it connects


← The Asian disease problem · Thinking inside frameworks (14 of 21) · Crime as beast, crime as virus →

Explore all the ideas · Read the book in order · Open the interactive map