Concept · part of Thinking inside frameworks

Strong chess players were shown a position with a familiar solution and a better one. They found the familiar one and said they were now looking for something better. A camera tracking their eyes showed them looking, again and again, at the squares involved in the solution they already had (chess-einstellung).

Psychologists call this the Einstellung effect, after a 1942 experiment with water jars: a method that has worked blocks the search for a better one. Its sibling is functional fixedness, where seeing an object only in its usual role stops you using it for anything else. The effect is robust, with a limit. When the familiar move was an outright blunder, every expert avoided it.

This is a framework installed by practice in place of design: a learned method acting as a default that captures attention. The book meets it at the scale of a whole career as the curse of expertise, and its close relative is the law of the instrument. The chess result carries a warning: the players believed they were searching freely. The defense is deliberate outside input (framework-rotation).

Read the full argument

How it connects


← Theory-ladenness and paradigms · Thinking inside frameworks (17 of 21) · Chess experts and the Einstellung effect →

Explore all the ideas · Read the book in order · Open the interactive map