Concept · part of Thinking inside frameworks
For centuries, astronomers who believed the planets moved in perfect circles around the Earth kept finding that the planets did not quite cooperate. Each time, they added another small circle on top of the old ones. The system never failed on its own terms, because there was always one more circle to add.
N. R. Hanson named the wider point the theory-ladenness of observation: what a scientist sees depends on the concepts brought to the looking. Thomas Kuhn widened it to whole communities. A paradigm tells a field which puzzles are worth solving and sets awkward results aside until they pile up into a crisis. A related point, from Duhem and Quine, is that evidence never tests one idea alone, so the framework decides which part gets blamed when a prediction fails. The extra circles are the classic case of it.
In the book’s vocabulary a paradigm is a specialist community’s shared reading instructions, the key its members decode every result with (the three layers of a message). That is why findings cross between fields so badly (transferable-preconditions), and why deep training can blind as well as equip (the curse of expertise, the Einstellung effect). It is a framework at the scale of a profession.
Read the full argument
- Thinking Inside Frameworks, section “A framework is a medium you think in”
How it connects
- Examples: AI benchmarks as milestones, The DSM and RDoC
- See also: Einstellung effect, The curse of expertise, The three-layer message (frame / outer / inner), Transferable preconditions
- Evidence: Frameworks That Shape the Thoughts Built Inside Them, The Structure of Scientific Revolutions
- Where the book discusses it: Thinking Inside Frameworks
← Crime as beast, crime as virus · Thinking inside frameworks (16 of 21) · Einstellung effect →
Explore all the ideas · Read the book in order · Open the interactive map