Concept · part of When the map moves the territory

A formula published in 1973 said what a financial option ought to cost. At first real prices matched it poorly. Then traders began pricing with it, and for about a decade real prices matched it closely. After the 1987 crash the match broke and never fully returned (black-scholes).

Donald MacKenzie calls this performativity. His image is that a financial model is “an engine, not a camera”: it helps drive the market it appears to photograph. When using a model makes the world more like the model, the model looks more and more correct, partly because it is being used. The reverse also happens, and use of a model can make the world less like it. MacKenzie is careful to add that not just any formula could have made itself true this way.

For the book this is the best-documented case of framework feedback, and a close relative of constitutive transmission, where spreading a belief helps make it so. It belongs with looping effects and Goodhart’s law. It is also why the map-and-territory warning falls short on its own: this map moves the ground.

Read the full argument

How it connects


← AI benchmarks as milestones · When the map moves the territory (10 of 17) · Black-Scholes and the option market →

Explore all the ideas · Read the book in order · Open the interactive map