Mechanism · part of When the map moves the territory
Suppose a city ranks its schools by test scores. Within a few years the schools have changed: more test preparation, less of everything the test does not cover. The scores rise. Whether the children know more is now hard to tell, because the thing that was supposed to tell you has been reshaped by being used.
Framework feedback is the loop in which a framework’s outputs get acted on and the world shifts in response. It can run toward the framework: foresters planted the tidy forest their tables described (scientific-forestry), and traders priced options by a formula until prices fit it (performativity). It can run away from it: a measure chased as a target stops measuring (Goodhart’s law), and people sorted into a category change, which changes the category (looping effects).
The book argues this is where a framework’s bias does its real damage. A biased map misleads its reader. A map that is acted on rebuilds the ground, and the mismatch that would have exposed it disappears. It is the general form of what the book calls constitutive transmission.
Read the full argument
- Thinking Inside Frameworks, section “When the map starts moving the territory”
How it connects
- Builds on: Constitutive transmission, Framework pricing
- Special cases: Goodhart’s law, Looping effects, Performativity
- Examples: Apartheid race classification, Black-Scholes and the option market, Scientific forestry and the Normalbaum, The Gaussian copula and 2008
- See also: Constitutive regimes (convergent / divergent / hollow), Legibility, The map is not the territory
- Evidence: Frameworks That Shape the Thoughts Built Inside Them
- Where the book discusses it: Chapter 10: Political Economy of Attention, Thinking Inside Frameworks
← The DSM and RDoC · When the map moves the territory (7 of 17) · Goodhart’s law →
Explore all the ideas · Read the book in order · Open the interactive map