Example · part of When the map moves the territory

In one South African family, one twin was classified as coloured and the other as African. The 1950 Population Registration Act and Group Areas Act required that every person be classified by racial group, and the classification decided where they could live and work. The first sorting came from the categories checked on 1951 census returns. The criteria were appearance and “general acceptance and repute,” enforced with devices such as the pencil test in the hair.

About 100,000 people applied to be reclassified. Appeals averaged 14 months, and the person waited in limbo. In 1984 alone, 795 people were reclassified, 518 of them from coloured to white.

Geoffrey Bowker and Susan Leigh Star analyze the case in Sorting Things Out. It is torque, their term, at its most extreme: the categories overrode family, biography and how people identified themselves. A legal race category is real in the sense the book’s three realities calls intersubjective, real because a society enforces it. Treating it as a found thing is reification. The census form made people legible to the state, and framework feedback did the rest: the categories remade the lives they claimed to describe.

The evidence is historical, drawn from one book’s analysis of the records.

How solid is this? Historical and documentary evidence from Bowker and Star’s Sorting Things Out (ch. 6); a case study, not an experiment.

How it connects


← Classification torque · When the map moves the territory (5 of 17) · The DSM and RDoC →

Explore all the ideas · Read the book in order · Open the interactive map