Concept · part of When the map moves the territory
Sort rocks into granite and basalt and the rocks do not care. Sort people into a diagnosis, a credit grade or a type of student and they notice. Some lean into the label, some fight it, some reorganize their lives around it. The group you end up with is no longer the group you first described.
Ian Hacking calls this a looping effect, and uses it to separate human kinds from natural kinds. A classification of people is a moving target, because the people classified respond to the classification, and that changes the people and therefore the category.
It is framework feedback applied to the sorting of human beings. It sits beside torque (what categories do to lives) and performativity (what models do to markets). It matters for the book’s account of things that are real because people agree on them (the three realities): a category of people is partly made by being used. The book has flagged Hacking’s work as owed a closer reading.
Read the full argument
- Thinking Inside Frameworks, section “When the map starts moving the territory”
How it connects
- A special case of: Framework feedback
- See also: Apartheid race classification, Classification torque, Constitutive transmission, Performativity, Three realities (Harari)
- Evidence: Frameworks That Shape the Thoughts Built Inside Them, The Social Construction of What?
- Where the book discusses it: Thinking Inside Frameworks
← The Gaussian copula and 2008 · When the map moves the territory (13 of 17) · Conway’s law →
Explore all the ideas · Read the book in order · Open the interactive map