Example · part of When the map moves the territory
The Black-Scholes-Merton model is a formula for pricing the financial contracts called options. From 1973 to 1976, market prices fit it poorly. Then traders started using it. From 1976 to the summer of 1987, prices converged on the model, partly through arbitrage that imposed its pricing. After the October 1987 crash a lasting departure appeared, the volatility skew. Even the skew is measured against the model’s flat line, and the model’s own parameter, implied volatility, became the market’s language for pricing options.
Donald MacKenzie, who documented these three phases, describes financial models as engines that shape markets, where a camera would only record them. This is performativity, and it is framework feedback in both directions: first toward the model, then away.
In the book’s terms, a market price is one of the intersubjective things, real because enough people agree on it. A model that spreads among the people who set the price takes part in making it, which the book calls constitutive transmission. The Gaussian copula is a related case.
MacKenzie is careful. Fitting the story does not prove it, he says, and an arbitrary formula could not have made itself true.
How solid is this? Compelling for options as one well-documented case, but MacKenzie himself says consistency with performativity does not prove it, and its general scope is debated.
Read the full argument
- Thinking Inside Frameworks, section “When the map starts moving the territory”
How it connects
- What it shows: Constitutive transmission, Framework feedback, Performativity
- See also: The Gaussian copula and 2008, Three realities (Harari)
- Evidence: An Engine, Not a Camera: How Financial Models Shape Markets, Frameworks That Shape the Thoughts Built Inside Them
- Where the book discusses it: Thinking Inside Frameworks
← Performativity · When the map moves the territory (11 of 17) · The Gaussian copula and 2008 →
Explore all the ideas · Read the book in order · Open the interactive map